An Accountability System For Financial Institutions in Canada: How To Ensure They Meet a High Standard of Performance
CCRC Position Paper #5 Summary
Canada's banks have reaped enormous benefits from decades of privileges and protection granted by Canadian governments, including a huge growth in assets, market dominance and record profits. The Big Five banks are the largest corporations in Canada, based on assets. Each bank's assets are greater than the federal government's annual revenues and together they control a large majority ($1 trillion) of all deposit-taking institution assets, trust companies, investment company assets, small business, consumer credit & mortgage lending. Big Five bank profits have more than doubled since 1993, and in 1997 the Royal Bank had the highest corporate profit ever in Canada.
Given that the banks would not be as large or profitable as they are without these privileges and protections, and the deposits of over 20 million Canadians, banks are in position of public trust with regard to the money they manage. Yet many Canadians are not satisfied with the banks' performance. Surveys in 1996 and 1997 by the National Quality Institute of over 8,000 Canadians found that banks ranked in the bottom five of 21 industries in terms of customer satisfaction. And small businesses have consistently ranked access to capital as one of their top 10 concerns in annual surveys over the past decade.
Based on their position of public trust, and on the problems faced by financial consumers and small businesses, the Canadian Community Reinvestment Coalition (CCRC) is urging the federal government to enact legislation to ensure that banks and other financial institutions serve all customers fairly and well. The federal government has recognized the need for regulation of the financial services sector. As the discussion paper on the 1997 Review of Financial Sector Legislation stated:
"There is no question that regulations are required in the financial sector. Regulations not only protect the consumer, they set out the rules of the game so that the sector can operate smoothly." (p.19).
Unfortunately the federal government has failed to enact effective measures to hold financial institutions accountable to consumer, small business and community interests on key issues of concern.
Laws in the U.S. have worked well for 20 years to ensure that financial institutions meet the needs of communities in which they have branches. It's s worth noting that both the Bank of Montreal and the Toronto-Dominion own U.S. financial institutions that comply with U.S. community accountability laws, while still providing a significant percentage of each bank's overall profits. Based on the U.S. system, the CCRC proposes that the federal government enact requirements for banks and other financial institutions to do the following:
In essence, this information would reveal the demand for capital by different sizes and types of businesses, and whether financial institutions are meeting the demand. The Liberal, Progressive Conservative, NDP and Bloc Quebecois parties have all called in their policies or election platforms in the past year for similar requirements to be enacted in Canada. The CCRC also proposes that the federal government enact the following requirements to determine how well financial institutions are serving consumers in each community by requiring each institution to disclose each year:
The CCRC urges that, after a two-year transition period to develop the evaluation system, the following incentives should apply to financial institutions to encourage them to improve their performance:
In addition, as detailed in the CCRC's other four position papers, banks and other financial institutions, including foreign financial institutions operating in Canada, should be required to:
These are reasonable ways to require banks and other financial institutions to meet a high standard of performance in serving Canadians, based upon a U.S. system that has worked effectively for 20 years.
Canadian Community Reinvestment Coalition
P.O.Box 1040, Station B,
Ottawa, Canada K1P 5R1
Tel: (613) 789-5753
Fax: (613) 241-4758
Copyright 1997 CCRC